Upper Santonian Guide Fossils

The fossils below were found in the Smoky Hill Member of the Blue Gate Shale (Mancos Group) in east central Utah. 

Desmoscaphites bassleri Reeside 1927, from the upper Upper Santonian.

Uintacrinus socialis Grinnel. 1876, from the middle Upper Santonian.

As reported in a poster by Bylund, Scheetz, and Kittrick, 2025

Scaphites leei Reeside, 1927, form I Cobban, 1969, also from the middle Upper Santonian,

Clioscaphites choteauensis Cobban, 1952, from the lower Upper Santonian.

Except for the crinoids they are all external molds of the shell.

Clioscaphites from the Emery Sandstone

The Emery Sandstone

    The Emery Sandstone as exposed in western Emery County, Utah consists of 4 or 5 thin sandstone beds that thicken rapidly sub-surface to the west.  Cephalopods preserved in the formation, mostly as internal molds, include the Nautiloid Eutrephoceras sp., and the ammonites Placenticeras syrtale, Baculites codyensis, and Clioscaphites vermiformis in the lower beds and Desmoscaphites bassleri in the uppermost bed.  Desmoscaphites bassleri Reeside, 1927, is an Index Fossil for the Upper Santonian (Upper Cretaceous), Clioscaphites vermiformis (Meek & Hayden, 1862), for the Middle Santonian, and C. saxitonianus (Mclearn, 1929) for the Lower Santonian.

    The trouble with finding only a few fossils in a few beds is that intermediates always seem to creep into the section.  The main difference between C. vermiformis and the underlying C. saxitonianus is the strength of the sculpture, pointed tubercles in C. vermiformis, and insipient nodes in C. saxitonianus. The lobe of the suture is another difference, being trifid in C. vermiformis and mostly bifid in C. saxitonianus, but rarely preserved in Emery fossils because the phragmocones are usually crushed.

    Below are photos and 3D models of a couple of fossils from the lower Emery Sandstone (Garley Canyon Beds).  The upper photos show a typical C. vermiformis with its strong sculpture and pointed tubercles. The lower photos show a specimen from the lowest bed of the Emery, still with strong sculpture but without a pointed tubercle, more of a strong 90° rib.  The sculpture on the lower specimen is stronger than typical C. saxitonianus, even stronger than C. saxitonianus var. keytei Cobban, 1952 (which by itself could be a new species).  Not being one to split, it's probably best to leave it in C. vermiformis for now and just consider it an intermediate until more specimens or one showing the suture can be found.

Clioscaphites vermiformis.  Specimen, left, 3D Model, right.  From a sandstone bed in the middle of the Emery Sandstone.

Clioscaphites ?vermiformis, Specimen, left, 3D model, right.  From the lowest sandstone bed in the Emery Sandstone.

The Canadian System (Period) as proposed by Flower (1957)

Because the Cephalopods were so different, Rousseau H. Flower wrote proposing the Canadian System with four divisions of unspecified rank (Flower 1957 p. 17).  Quoting from Flower:

"Faunally, the Canadian is relatively isolated from the Ordovician above and is characterized by stocks of its own. In the cephalopods..., the Canadian-Ordovician boundary involves changes never lower than of generic rank, and generally of the rank of families and orders."

Someone looking at only, or mostly Cephalopod fossils could see the column this way. The four divisions are areas where Flower collected cephalopods. The Cassinian from the Ft. Cassin area in Vermont, the Jeffersonian from the Adirondacks in NY, the Demingian from the Florida Mts. in New Mexico, and the Gasconadian from the Ozark Mt. area of Missouri. I don't think his later collections in Utah and Nevada changed anything.  His boundary is just above Zone K, which is basically the Hesperonomiella minor bed (e.g. Li and Droser 1999) or the base of the Whiterockian Stage of the Ordovician.

Chart modified from Flower 1964 (p. 23, fig. 3) Ross-Hintze Zones on the right.

These days, the Canadian System of Flower (later referred to as the Canadian Series) has been replaced with the Ibexian Series (Ross et al., 1997) and the Lower Ordovician Series of the ICS.

References:

Flower, R.H., 1957, Studies of the Actinoceratida, Memoir 2, New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources, Socorro, NM.

Flower, R.H., 1964, The Nautiloid Order Ellesmeroceratida (Cephalopoda), Memoir 12, New Mexico Bureau of Mines and Mineral Resources, Socorro, NM.

Li, X., and Droser, M.L., 1999, Lower and Middle Ordovician Shell Beds from the Basin and Range Province of the Western United States (California, Nevada, and Utah) PALAIOS, V. 14.

Ross, R.J., Jr, Hintze, L.F., Ethington, R.L., Miller, J.F., Taylor, M.E. & Repetski, J.E., 1997, The Ibexian, lowermost series in the North American Ordovician. United States Geological Survey Professional Paper, 1579-A.

Latest Smithian Ammonoids in northern Utah

Corroborating the existence of a UAZ6 (Unitary Association Zone, a means of biostratigraphic correlation).  See the paper linked below.  Characterized by the ammonoid Psudosageceras augustum (Brayard & Bucher, 2008) in association with Xenoceltites subevolutus Spath 1930. Found in rocks previously assigned to the Induan (lower Lower Triassic) Dinwoody Fm., now assigned to the Olenekian (upper Lower Triassic, top of Smithian) Thaynes Group.

Pseudosageceras augustum left and Xenoceltites subevolutus right

Xenoceltites subevolutus left and Pseudosageceras augustum right

In press, Article in GEOBIOS

Available online 18 June 2021

Abstract

The late Smithian extinction represents a major event within the Early Triassic. This event generally corresponds to a succession of two and possibly three successively less diverse, cosmopolitan ammonoid assemblages, which when present, provide a robust biostratigraphic framework and precise correlations at different spatial scales. In the western USA basin, known occurrences of latest Smithian taxa are rare and until now, have only been documented from northeastern Nevada. Based on these restricted basinal occurrences, a regional zone representing the latest Smithian was postulated but not corroborated, as representative taxa had not yet been reported from outside Nevada. Here we document two new ammonoid assemblages from distant localities in northern Utah, overlying the late Smithian Anasibirites beds and characterized by the unambiguous co-occurrence of Xenoceltites subevolutus and Pseudosageceras augustum. The existence of a latest Smithian zone in the western USA basin is therefore validated, facilitating the identification of the Smithian/Spathian boundary and intra-basin correlation. This zone also correlates with the latest Smithian zone recognized from southern Tethyan basins. Additionally, these new data support other observed occurrences of Xenoceltites subevolutus throughout most of the late Smithian.